
Literary works exist as a method by which a creator can speak a meaning to a wider audience. Poetry, prose, and other written formats utilize conventions within their mediums to creatively express ideas about a subject. The manners in which these ideas are expressed, and which subjects they are expressed on, are endlessly variable. Serious topics, such as historical trauma, are a common subject expressed in many works and many art forms. When such topics are discussed properly in expressive works, they tend to be cultural hallmarks and works of respect within their respective field of ideas surrounding the serious topic. One such work that is commonly credited and critically recognized in this way is Art Spiegelman’s Maus. Concluded in 1991, it is a work that not only handles a Holocaust story with great care and effectiveness but does so through a graphic novel format, helping to break the medium into the mainstream. Maus also sparked great critical discussion stemming from Spiegelman’s use of animals in place of humans (“Art Spiegelman” par. 10). Thirty-seven years prior to the conclusion of Maus, the film Godzilla (1954) was released in Japan to great success and acclaim, marking the first work of one of the most popular science-fiction franchises ever. Godzilla started as a stark allegory for nuclear weaponry, but over time evolved and strayed away from its historical roots and is usually pigeonholed to being “kaiju-flicks,” a less serious subgenre of the film medium. While Maus and the Godzilla franchise are vastly different, their significant similarity is that they both deal with serious topics through unorthodox storytelling and formats, showcasing that they can be excellent at expressing ideas historical trauma. The merit of these works can invoke a greater involvement of unconventional works and subgenres into the literary canon.
Maus was published in two volumes, Maus I: My Father Bleeds History (1986) and Maus II: And Here my Troubles Began (1991), and later a combined version in 1994. It is not only a Holocaust story, but also a memoir of a man who lived with and was raised by a Holocaust survivor. Spiegelman wrote in the Village Voice that Maus was motivated “by an impulse to look dead-on at the root cause of my own deepest fears and nightmares” (qtd. in “Art Spiegelman” par. 9). Spiegelman controversially chose to tell this story through a graphic novel and allegorized Jews as mice and Nazis as cats, differing from the usually conservative and traditional style of Holocaust narratives noted by Schwarz (qtd. in Matthews 130). Maus won a Pulitzer Prize in 1992 and achieved wide public and critic recognition, with many emphasizing Spiegelman’s unique emphasis on form and self-insertion (“Art Spiegelman” par. 12). In the beginning pages of Maus II: And Here my Troubles Began, Spiegelman states his unwillingness to turn his comic into a film or television show (201). His stance has since not changed as in 2022 he told The Hollywood Reporter that he still will not move his work to the screen, stating that it “is better served as a book” (qtd. in Weinstein par. 2). Recognizing Spiegelman’s unwillingness to adapt Maus is important for understanding the work, his perspective, and the work’s intertextuality.
Maus not receiving an adaptation is sensible. Spiegelman in both his story and publicly has shown his careful and gripping ownership over the story he wanted to tell. In the first part of Maus, Vladek requests Spiegelman to not include the story of his relationship with a lover named Lucia because he thought the information was not proper and respectful, and that it had nothing to do with the Holocaust (Spiegelman 25). Spiegelman reasons that including such information makes Vladek appear more human and thus makes the story more real, but Vladek reaffirms his unwillingness. Ultimately, Vladek’s story with Lucia is included, showcasing Spiegelman’s emphasis of having full autonomy in his story and not allowing others to tamper with it. He corroborated this sentiment in a 1997 lecture, stating “I get the last word rather than Vladek since it’s my book” (qtd. in Ewert 90).


Spiegelman likely fears that an adaptation to a different medium would not be, in his eyes, a work that fits his serious vision and goals for Maus. There are aspects of Maus that may not translate well to other mediums, including Spiegelman’s depictions of human beings and ethnicities as animals. The comic form, unlike the serious novel form, was associated with whimsical stories and children’s entertainment (Matthews 132). Perceptions of comic representation may have made Spiegelman’s depiction more digestible, but public reception of Jewish people portrayed as mice on the film screen would likely be less accepting. Additionally, Spiegelman’s story’s effectiveness is reliant on the strengths and capabilities of the graphic novel medium, and there are numerous concrete examples.
A film is constantly moving at its own pace, and the audience is not given the time to analyze everything at their discretion. In a graphic novel, time is the reader’s to play with. A reader has complete autonomy and time to look through an entire page to not only read the texts, but to read the visuals and interpret meaning. When Vladek returns home from forced military service and has dinner with his family, his son Richieu is depicted by Spiegelman having thrown a tantrum at the table, despite this instance not being relayed by Vladek to Spiegelman. Later on in the story, Spiegelman tells his wife Francoise that his parents only had a photo of Richieu in their room, and that “the photo never threw tantrums or got in any kind of trouble” (175). It is apparent that Spiegelman felt that he was always in Richieu’s shadow to his parents, and inserting an instance of Richieu throwing a tantrum reveals his feelings about the situation. Spiegelman could not know whether Richieu actually threw that tantrum, but he utilizes the capabilities of graphic novel form to emphasize one of his principal feelings about growing up as a Holocaust survivor (Ewert 88).
A later instance of Spiegelman using visual narrative is when he, Francoise, and Vladek encounter a black hitchhiker on the way home from grocery shopping, and Francoise allows the man in the car. Vladek calls the man a “shvartser” and tells Francoise that she lost her head as the man could have stolen their groceries. Vladek is rebuked by Francoise for his racism, as she correctly argues that he of all people being a racist is outrageous. Vladek replies, “It’s not even to compare the shvartsers and the Jews!” (Spiegelman 259). When they finally arrive home in the final panel of the chapter, Vladek is happy to make lunch with the groceries and can “only thank God that your shvarster didn’t take them” (Spiegelman 260). In this panel, Vladek is depicted to be completely dark rather than the usual white color Spiegelman depicts him and the other mice to be. Given his attention to details, such as gradually removing tails from the mice characters throughout the story (Ewert 100), it is unlikely that this dark depiction does not have significance. It could be interpreted that Spiegelman believes racism, particularly from groups that have experienced it, is ironic. Vladek should understand what it’s like to be racially prejudiced yet still acts incredibly racist. By depicting Vladek as dark, and allegorically in the same situation as a black man, Spiegelman tells the reader that Vladek and the black man share the trait of being on the receiving end of race-based terrible acts (Holocaust and slavery) and calls upon the idea that racism is so pervasive that even those who experience it still practice it. Spiegelman again utilizes the capabilities of the graphic novel medium to make a subtle connection, and a moment that would not translate well to a screen. Vladek suddenly turning dark would be too disruptive to an audience, nonsensical for a film, and would not hit the same subtle notes that it does in a graphic novel.
Intertextuality, to many, exists where there is a line of works that relate to each other in re-interpreting ideas through a variety of media in a new cultural context, and usually correlates with adaptations (Orr par. 5). Maus will not get any adaptations, but it still has important intertextuality in other ways that showcase its significance and literary merit. Spiegelman’s story had an immense influence on graphic novel storytelling and techniques of the medium. Two landmark graphic novel works that followed Maus, Joe Sacco’s Palestine (1993) and Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis (2000), both portray historical traumatic events through intensive and complex visual modes similar to Spiegelman (Chute 459). Hajime Isayama’s manga Shingeki no Kyojin (2009), which contains elements parallel to World War II, helped pedal western popularity among younger demographics for manga and anime in the 2010s. A large part of its success can be attributed to its style where readers can infer how the world operates and have information to excavate through visuals, thus bypassing Isayama’s theme of control that grips the characters (Ursini par. 44). This medium-specific mechanism is present in Spiegelman’s work in aforementioned examples, and shows that despite its lack in adaptation, Maus has a major role in the intertextual web of storytelling of historical tragedies through its pioneering techniques in visual narrative.
The role of Maus in graphic novel’s intertextual web can not be understated, but it is also complemented by the work’s contributions to Holocaust storytelling. The editors of An Anthology of Holocaust Literature (1975) explain that Holocaust literature should come from firsthand survivors, be realistic, arise from confirmable facts, and utilizes an authentic Jewish voice (Gordon 86). Spiegelman breaks three out of four of these rules, the exception being that his story does arise from confirmable facts (aside from occasional author insertions such as the previously mentioned Richieu’s tantrums). Through straying away from the conventions of Holocaust narratives, Spiegelman creates precedent for approaching Holocaust storytelling from new angles and new perspectives. The story is from Artie’s perspective, not Vladek’s, emphasizing the long term generational effects of the Holocaust that goes beyond just direct victims. Spiegelman’s story is not “realistic” in the sense that it depicts animals in place of people, but this artistic decision explores stereotypes and brings out Spiegelman’s feelings- a privilege that belongs to him as author. His “inauthentic” Jewish voice can be cited as his depiction of himself wearing a Jewish mouse mask while writing his comic, as if he feels disconnected from his heritage through his writing (Gordon 86). It can be interpreted he feels this disconnect due to his volatile relationship with his parents and their experience in the Holocaust, as his story is an exploration of himself and his perspectives rather than entirely the Holocaust itself. Maus’s exploration of new art forms of expression and approaches to the Holocaust mark it as a key work in the intertextual web of Holocaust ideas.

Maus is a unique work for its precise form and intertextual presence despite a lack in adaptation. It is highly regarded and broke graphic novels into being perceived as a more serious art form and has made its way into classrooms. Indeed, the Godzilla franchise to most would seem to be a far-fetched and not strong comparison. While there are many differences between the two works, an exploration of the Godzilla franchise reveals many merits and nuances of its unique allegories, storytelling, interpretation, and broad intertextuality. These qualities are present in both Maus and Godzilla and pedal them towards their success in reflecting upon historical disasters. Godzilla’s long extended history warrants an examination that deems it a more serious work than it is given credit for, and the franchise started dramatically.
After the end of World War II, Japan was heavily wounded and looking towards reconstruction. In March of 1954, a United States hydrogen bomb test near Bikini Atoll in the Marshall Islands resulted in a Japanese fishing boat being exposed to radioactive fallout, resulting in crew sickness and the death of ship radioman Aikichi Kuboyama (Kalat 33). Still feeling the scars of the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Toho Studios producer Tomoyuki Tanaka came up with a new project after the original planned 1954 release Beyond the Glory fell through (Kalat 13). Tanaka’s idea was to combine aspects of the 1933 blockbuster King Kong with modern fears of radiation and nuclear power, and he enlisted writer Shigeru Kayama to draw up a story outline that would impress Toho executives, thus began Godzilla (Kalat 14). The subsequent hiring of director Ishiro Honda would transform the film’s vision from an American style monster film with radiation as a narrative device to that of a monster symbolizing radiation itself, reflecting the despair of the atomic bombings (Kalat 15).

Image Source: Wikipedia
Godzilla (1954) follows paleontologist Dr. Yamane, his daughter Emiko, Emiko’s arranged marriage fiancé and Yamane’s colleague Dr. Serizawa, and Lieutenant Ogata, Emiko’s love interest. After a monster creature that gets named Godzilla appears on an island, Yamane concludes that the monster is a prehistoric creature awakened by recent hydrogen bomb tests, and that the creature itself is radioactive, since it emits a destructive radiation ray. The government attempted to hide the existence of Godzilla from the public to avoid panic and tension in diplomatic relations, while Yamane expresses interest in studying the creature. Serizawa confesses to Emiko that he has created a super weapon more deadly than nuclear power: the oxygen destroyer; he asks a horrified Emiko to keep it a secret until he finds a beneficial use for it, and she agrees. Godzilla gets to Tokyo and utterly decimates it, killing everything in his path and filling hospitals with radiation-poisoned children. Emiko’s sanity slips and she tells Ogata what she saw. Ogata confronts Serizawa to use the oxygen destroyer. Serizawa refuses, citing “Ogata, if the oxygen destroyer is used even once, the politicians of the world won’t stand idly by. They’ll inevitably turn it into a weapon” (Godzilla 1:19:24- 1:19:38). After seeing an emotional television broadcast of children singing a hymn begging for the return of peace, Serizawa finally agrees to utilize the oxygen destroyer to kill Godzilla. In a naval mission, Ogata and Serizawa are dropped down by rope to Godzilla’s resting lair, and, after planting the device, Serizawa cuts his rope ensuring that he and knowledge of his weapon will die along with Godzilla. The film ends with Dr. Yamane proclaiming, “If we continue nuclear testing, others of Godzilla’s kind will appear somewhere around the world” (Godzilla 1:35:35- 1:35-45).
Godzilla, unlike the sensationalistic Hollywood monster movies of its time, is dark, dreadful, and presents an unmatched atmosphere that dwells on pain and suffering. Its narrative is complex and engages relevant themes including the dangers of nuclear weaponry and the distrust of man. Godzilla itself is a walking allegory: a godlike being created from man’s playing of God and carelessness in creating destructive power. Memories of the atomic bombs and the recent lucky dragon incident were fresh in the minds of Japanese viewers as they witnessed Godzilla emerge from the sea (Kalat 33). Godzilla is depicted as an animal that simply destroys and displays no discernible emotion, akin to atomic weaponry. The concept of a radiation ridden dinosaur-like monster attacking Tokyo is an unorthodox and fantastical approach to nuclear issues, unlike other works such as Children of Hiroshima (1952), but through its excellent execution in narrative and filmography, the film succeeds in telling a nuanced story that helped an ailing nation make sense of total disaster.
The distrust of man is a prevalent theme of Godzilla and is shown explicitly in the character of Dr. Serizawa. He was unwilling to use the oxygen destroyer out of fear of what man would do with it, and references nuclear weaponry when he exclaims “A-bombs against A-bombs, H-bombs against H-bombs… adding another terrifying weapon to humanity’s arsenal is something I can’t allow” (Godzilla 1:19:39-1:19:53). The film presents a moral debate with no clear winner, and Serizawa likely only agrees because he plans to kill himself along with his weapon. The ending does not provide a gratification or the sense of a hero’s victory with the death of Godzilla, but rather a dark shadow cast over as it is realized the capability of man to create monsters (“Up from the Depths Reviews | Godzilla (1954) 3:39-3:58).” The strength of Godzilla also lies in its excellent uses of the film medium, with talented special effects artist Eji Tsuburaya crafting impressive sequences of realistic destruction, and composer Akira Ifukube creating an incredible score that brings terror and emotion to Godzilla’s destruction.

Toho’s great cinematic achievement would begin an iconic franchise with decades of films. Godzilla is split into multiple eras: the Showa era (15 films spanning from 1954-1975), the Heisei era (7 films spanning from 1984-1995), the Millennium era (6 films spanning from 2000-2004), the Monsterverse era (so far, five films including Kong Skull Island, spanning from 2014-2024), and the Reiwa era (so far, five films spanning from 2016-2023). Each era has its own distinctive characteristics, and importantly interpretation, of the character Godzilla. An analysis of specific films of the Showa and Heisei eras reveal Godzilla’s most drastic evolutions, while the Millennium and Reiwa eras perform more adaptive and experimental approaches to pre-existing formulas. The significance and meaning of these different uses of Godzilla reveals the complex and intricate intertextuality of the franchise: continually spinning strands into the large web of ideas of a symbol of nuclear disaster and its relationship with humanity.
The Showa era starts seriously with the original dark film but gradually evolves into a campier series with absurd plotlines and the conversion of Godzilla into a superhero for children. Within the era there are many acclaimed films, such as Godzilla vs. Mothra (1964), which made subtle commentaries on greedy consumerism; Invasion of Astro Monster (1965), which was the first film in the franchise to depict Godzilla as a hero to defend Earth from external forces, and Godzilla vs Hedorah (1971), where Godzilla’s opponent Hedorah is an explicit allegory for pollution. As the era progressed, numerous factors arose that caused the changes to Godzilla’s character. Director Ishiro Honda’s involvement was phased out over time (Kalat 109), gradually declining ticket sales and budgets resulted in rampant use of stock footage, and Godzilla’s marketability to children rather than adults resulted in the divisive and heavily criticized films of the late 1960s and the early 1970s (Kalat 100). No film better exemplifies this drastic change in Showa era Godzilla, while also revealing the character’s incredible intertextuality, than All Monsters Attack (1969), often considered one of (if not the) worst Godzilla film (Chernov par. 5, “All Monsters Attack”). A closer analysis of this universally panned film showcases a subtle, culturally relevant story that heightens Godzilla’s intertextuality and complexity.
All Monsters Attack follows a young rambunctious boy named Ichiro of busy working class parents and lives in an industrial apartment complex. He loves Godzilla, is tormented by bullies led by Gabbara, and usually spends his time alone or with his neighbor Inami who instructs him to fight his own battles. Ichiro begins to daydream and creates an inner fantasy where he hangs out with Godzilla’s son Minya on Monster Island and watches Godzilla in action. Minya, like Ichiro, is being bullied by a monster named Gabbara, and usually runs to his father for help but Godzilla forces Minya to stand up to Gabbara on his own in which Minya eventually succeeds. Meanwhile in real life, Ichiro has been kidnapped by two incompetent robbers. Inspired by Minya, Ichiro stands up to the robbers by biting them and helps the police catch them. Ichiro’s mother, who worked an overnight shift, is devastated and tells Ichiro that she will not work overnight again, to which he replies, “don’t we need the money?” She cries as a result of what happened and their current situation. Ichiro confronts and defends himself against his bully Gabbara, messes with a painter, and frolics into the distance (Kalat 101-102). Any viewer who had seen the original horrifying Godzilla (1954) would scoff at the childlike and ridiculous plotline in this film. Yet, underneath the copious amounts of stock footage and shenanigans lies deep messaging about role models, a critique of 1960s industrial Japan, and escapism.
Both Godzilla and Ichiro’s father are not good role models for their sons. Honda does well to depict Godzilla and Minya’s relationship as distant to parallel Ichiro’s relationship with his father by reshooting the scene where Godzilla teaches Minya how to breathe fire, rather than using stock footage from Son of Godzilla (1967) like most of the film does (Kalat 102). Godzilla often leaves Minya unattended to fight monsters, and Ichiro’s father is absent from his son’s life due to work. While Ichiro’s father needs to work and does not have a choice due to their family’s economic situation, this is likely not apparent to Ichiro. Ichiro is a young, usually jovial boy that is creating his own power fantasy that reflects his thoughts and desires. He wants his father to help him stand up to his bullies, just like Minya does, but he learns that he must fend for himself. Godzilla historians Stuart Galbraith and Greg Shoemaker criticize the film’s convoluted messaging, stating that Ichiro only fends off his own bullies by “becoming an even bigger bully” (qtd. in Kalat 103). Ichiro becomes a bigger bully because his only role models, Godzilla and Minya, are self-created and not strong role models in the slightest. Godzilla himself is a bully, beating down other monsters (including Gabbara) out of enjoyment rather than defense, which both Minya and Ichiro observe. Rather than other possible solutions to his bullying problem, Ichiro simply attacks the child Gabbara to earn validation and approval, which also marks the reason that he messes with the painter at the end of the film. Godzilla in this film may not be depicted as a harsh nuclear allegory, but he is used brilliantly and subtly as a plot device to highlight other issues some may find outrageous for a rubber suit monster film directed towards children.


Japan’s “economic miracle” was marked by an increase in workforce and industrialization but resulted in middle class people like Ichiro’s family becoming cogs in the wheel (Kalat 104). The film often highlights shots of Ichiro’s environment (such as polluted air and factories), particularly the morning after Ichiro escapes the robbers to highlight that the faulty world around him has not changed (“The History of All Monsters Attack (1969)” 25:22-25:36). The film clearly juxtaposes Ichiro’s mindset against the real-life situation he is in. His mother weeps for her son because of the situation their society has placed them in, while Ichiro finds happiness in self-delusion and escapism (Kalat 104). All Monsters Attack is also the only film in the entire franchise where the monsters are fictional, meaning that Ichiro has the same relationship with Godzilla that the viewer has. Fans of Godzilla have always faced ridicule and confusion at their obsession with a radioactive monster franchise with many films directed towards children, and despite the various explanations they may provide, the fundamental reason many are such great fans of Godzilla is a deep childhood innocence and attachment to nostalgic memories (Kalat 105). The film conducts a realistic examination of the franchise’s own fans, and the role of escapism to maintain sanity during times of distress. Role models, industrial Japanese society, and escapism all play a part with each other to enhance the intended message about each one. Even in what many consider the Showa era’s worst moment, Godzilla is used in a unique and culturally relevant way that highlights how far the character has come in the intertextual web of the franchise, emphasizing the series’ merit.
Following a nine-year hiatus, The Return of Godzilla (1984) would release, marking new beginnings for the monster in the Heisei series. Heisei films are different from the Showa era in many ways. The films have definitive continuity, a more serious tone, and most significantly, Godzilla is depicted much differently. Godzilla’s design is tall, imposing, and remains the same from the second film Godzilla vs. Biollante (1989) to the seventh and final film Godzilla vs. Destroyah (1995), rather than the constant changing as it did during the Showa era. Godzilla’s character is shifted significantly, as it is now more animal like, but not entirely like the villainous animal in the original film. Godzilla is a sentient anti-hero: a force of nature that mankind fears and fights against, but a force that aids mankind when a larger threat appears (“Remembering the Heisei Series” 3:29-3:37). This duality and complexity in Godzilla’s character highlights how far a cultural symbol has come since its inception, and a film that is regarded for exploring this symbol’s complex relationship with Japan is Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah (1991).
Following the events of Godzilla vs. Biollante, Japan is seeking a way to finally rid its world of Godzilla and continue to propel its economic prosperity, led by WWII veteran turned economist Yosuaki Shindo. Suddenly, a mysterious group of people appear including two foreigners and a Japanese woman named Emiko who claim to be from the future. They warn that action must be taken to prevent Japan from being eradicated by Godzilla, so they assert the need to travel back in time to prevent Godzilla’s existence. The group made up of the futurians and Japanese leaders travel back to WWII and witness Japanese forces, led by Shindo, being saved from an American attack by a dinosaur that gravely injures itself in the process. The injured dinosaur is then transported off the island into the Bering Sea to prevent it from turning into Godzilla through nuclear bomb testing. The group leaves, but not before Emiko drops off three future pets called Dorats onto the island. Back in the future, King Ghidorah is terrorizing Japan as it is revealed that the futurians are actually members of a radical group named Equal Environment of Earth that came to the past to prevent Japan from becoming an economic powerhouse that buys up multiple nations and creating a power imbalance. Emiko is betrayed, as she was tricked by a false plan that King Ghidorah would be used to force Japan to surrender, not be completely destroyed. Shindo comes up with a plan to use his company’s submarine’s nuclear missiles to create a new Godzilla; however, did not know that the dinosaur (now a dormant Godzilla) had already been managing to survive due to nuclear energy from an abandoned nuclear submarine, and Godzilla after consuming Shindo’s sub becomes more powerful than ever. Godzilla rises out of the sea, defeats King Ghidorah, and then turns around to destroy Japan like usual, killing Shindo after an emotional stare down. Emiko travels back to the future to grab King Ghidorah from the bottom of the ocean, repairing it, and then bringing it back to the past as Mecha-King Ghidorah. Emiko controls the new beast against Godzilla, but to no avail as Godzilla once again is victorious and Emiko barely escapes with her life as Godzilla returns to the sea, alive and more threatening than ever.
Outrageous storylines and lazy time-travel plot holes aside, Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah is one of the most interesting films of the franchise for its contributions to Godzilla’s intertextual web. The film completely revamps Godzilla’s origin story, begins its path as a sentient animal, and examines Godzilla’s relationship with Japan. Godzilla is a villain, then flips to become a hero, then flips again to become a villain, while Ghidorah starts as a villain and then becomes a hero. These radical changes establish the idea that perhaps these monsters are not in essence evil or good, but man’s manipulation of them guides what they are and their perception. The film’s responsibility in addressing historical context is mixed. By 1990, Japan’s economic boom included Sony purchasing Columbia Pictures and Matushita Electric Industrial Co. purchasing MCA/Universal, resulting in some anti-Japanese sentiment in the American press and filmmaking community (Kalat 192). American reviewers were upset by the film depicting Americans (one of the futurians is connected to represent America, the other Russia) as evil, perhaps a fair criticism as the film heavily hyperbolized the sentiment towards Japanese economic prosperity. To hold this against the film however is nonsensical, as Emiko’s entire character is a Japanese person who acknowledges the issues with Japan, works to stop them, but fights hard out of belief that the future Japan will be part of an equitable balance of power (Kalat 192). The most significant subtext in the film, however, is the character Shindo and his relationship with Godzilla.
Shindo, after being saved, always had a deep respect and affinity for the dinosaur (Godzilla) years after his salvation. He refused to evacuate his building during Godzilla’s destruction, stating that this is the way he wanted to go. Godzilla approaches his building, and through the window they engage in a long, silent, emotional stare down. As the camera pans on Shindo, it flashes back to the wounded dinosaur on Lagos Island. When the camera pans on a suffering, sorrowful Godzilla, it flashes back to Shindo saluting as a commander. Shindo gives Godzilla a nod, and after letting out a remorseful roar, Godzilla blasts him with atomic breath (“Godzilla vs King Ghidorah (1991) – Best Scene.” 0:00-2:17). This scene has been interpreted in different ways. One is that Godzilla kills Shindo out of hatred because Shindo (and thus humanity) abandoned it to die on the island. Another is that Godzilla is angry and hates humanity for creating it, but remembers Shindo respecting its sacrifice on Lagos island, resulting in sadness and confusion. Lastly, Shindo felt guilty for abandoning the dinosaur on the island, creating Godzilla once again to suffer through the forced task of saving humanity, and dooming his own nation he helped to build up, and allows Godzilla to kill him (“Tear Jerker Moments in Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah” par. 2-4). One thing is for certain: Shindo wanted to die to Godzilla and felt indebted towards it in some manner. Their relationship can be correlated to the relationship that Godzilla, and thus nuclear irresponsibility, has with humanity in many films. Godzilla was created by humanity, and humanity seeks to destroy it by changing time, but it is no use as not only was Godzilla created anyway by a separate nuclear entity, but Japan is forced to bring Godzilla back to save them. Humanity simply can’t erase nuclear disaster, the monster they created, from their history. Despite erasing the symbol of nuclear irresponsibility, humanity is still attacked indirectly because of its corruption in the form of King Ghidorah. Godzilla, and thus falling victim to nuclear disaster, will always be an inerasable part of Japan. Shindo accepts his faults in creating the monster decimating the nation before him and dies with that closure, which demonstrates the most important fundamental understanding towards nuclear disaster that is established in the very first film of the franchise. Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah is a landmark film that demonstrates how far Godzilla has come in its intertextual web, cultural implications, and layers of interpretation.

The mid-1990s would bring heavy anticipation for the first American made Godzilla movie that started production. Godzilla (1998) would eventually release and receive significant criticism. Director Roland Emmerich took full creative control, stating, “I didn’t want to make the original Godzilla. I wanted nothing to do with it. I wanted to make my own” (qtd. in “The History and Evolution of Godzilla” 33:07-33:13). Godzilla’s design would be changed drastically to look more like an iguana, had similar mannerisms to the T-Rex in A Lost World: Jurassic Park (1997), and laid eggs that hatched baby Godzillas that attacked similarly to the velociraptors of Jurassic Park (1993). While Godzilla has proven capability to be interpreted and utilized in a variety of ways, and any artist has autonomy over their work, Emmerich unfortunately missed the mark in a lot of ways. A severe altering of Godzilla’s design, changing its mannerisms and power, poor writing and acting, a constant semblance to the Jurassic Park series, and a lack of poignant messaging that many Toho films possess, led to a universally panned film that many simply label as not being a Godzilla movie. The cultural gap and lack of understanding of Godzilla in the United States was fully manifested, and thus Toho felt the need to handle Godzilla again.
The planned TriStar trilogy and hiatus for Toho films were canceled, and Toho produced and released Godzilla 2000: Millenium (1999), thus beginning the millennium era. This era is a complete reboot that disregards any previous films, and unlike the Heisei era, it is episodic. The films mostly go back to previously done formulas while incorporating newer ideas of storytelling, and utilizing special effects not previously seen in the franchise. A particular film that highlights the strengths of the millennium era is Godzilla, Mothra, and King Ghidorah: Giant Monsters All-Out Attack (2001), where Godzilla is a villain haunted by the spirits of victims of the Japanese during World War II, adding another manner in which Godzilla is an incarnation of man’s misdeeds. The millennium era would conclude with Godzilla’s 50th anniversary film, Godzilla Final Wars (2004), a rumble that is layered with western spectacle and action with humans just as involved in over-the-top battles like the monsters, but lacking in heavy substance (“Up from the Depths Reviews | Godzilla: Final Wars (2004) 2:25-3:07).
The millennium era is met with mixed critical reception. Godzilla vs. Megaguirus (2000) would perform poorly financially and many were tired of the monster vs. monster formula (“The History and Evolution of Godzilla” 37:55-38:02). Godzilla Against Mechagodzilla (2002) and its sequel Godzilla: Tokyo S.O.S. (2003) would both perform well while 50th anniversary film and final of the millennium era, Godzilla: Final Wars (2004), would underperform financially despite its high budget, although it did well critically (“The History and Evolution of Godzilla” 40:58-41:18). The millennium era is looked back on fondly for its experimentation with Godzilla and thus expanding the character’s intertextuality. Particularly, Godzilla: Final Wars experiments heavily with involving humans directly in the conflict of the movie against alien forces alongside the monsters, rather than having them standing by and watch. During the final fight, the protagonist is battling the alien leader in hand to hand combat while Godzilla is engaged in combat with its final opponent Monster X, and their motions are mirrored (Godzilla: Final Wars 1:44:56-1:45:07). Toho, in its last hoorah, depicted Godzilla as one in the same with a human fighting on behalf of earth. Godzilla is a representation of the nuclear disaster Japan experienced, but this interpretation of Godzilla showcases that the creature (and thus the disaster) is a part of what Japan is and they reclaim the tragedy and use the experience to fight against injustices.

Following another hiatus, the two current Godzilla eras, the Monsterverse era and the Reiwa era would begin relatively in the same time frame, 2014 and 2016 respectively. Legendary Pictures would release Godzilla (2014) and the film would succeed financially and stage appeal to wide audiences, and is considered to be a successful American adaptation of the faithful Japanese Godzilla formula (“Up From The Depths Reviews | Godzilla (2014)” 7:11-7:40). The film currently has 3 sequels with Godzilla, Godzilla: King of the Monsters (2019), Godzilla vs. Kong (2021), and Godzilla x Kong: The New Empire (2024). These sequels are considered to be less grounded than the 2014 blockbuster, with more astonishing plotlines and focus on monster spectacle than human plot elements. The films succeed in innovating the creatures from Godzilla’s mythos and creating entertaining battles but lose track in strong plotlines and narrative elements. It is likely this shift in focus was in response to criticisms of the 2014 film having too little screentime of Godzilla and too much focus on human characters. For many, this style is perfectly sufficient, but for others, this approach does not serve Godzilla well.
Daniel J. Durkin III argues that these films remove the integral themes of the Toho films since America is being attacked rather than Japan, and that the films state that Godzilla was created by American attempts to kill it rather than stating that U.S. nuclear tests created Godzilla (Durkin III 128). Considering that many themes throughout the Godzilla franchise were specifically relevant for Japanese experiences and zeitgeists, some may conclude that unless American films tackle these same themes in the same manner (that often antagonize America), they will be considered removed from the integral spirit of Toho Godzilla films. This expectation, however, is rather unreasonable. An American Godzilla film would be incapable of being a film that reflects Japanese experience and perspective concretely because the creators of these films have not had those experiences. Rather, the films should be interpreted as self-contained creations that expand the intertextuality of Godzilla through a new cultural lens and new zeitgeist, which these films succeed in. Godzilla started and was utilized many times in relation to Japan, but it can still be a symbol of anti-war or anti-weapons of mass destruction to any other nation, as these themes can and should be universal.
The Reiwa Era would begin with Shin Godzilla (2016), a film that is critically acclaimed and executed greatly through its direction, atmosphere, and commentary. It is a vastly different Godzilla film than its predecessors: Godzilla takes multiple forms, its design is much different, and it has an apocalyptic horror feel that is only similar to the original 1954 film. Directors Hideaki Anno and Shinji Iguchi tell a story in the wake of the “3.11” disasters, which began with a 9.1 earthquake on March 11, 2011, decimating Japan and resulting in a tsunami causing the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant to melt down and cause radioactive contamination (Newell 42-43). The film clearly shows its frustration with government bureaucracy, as nearly every member of the Japanese government is portrayed as lacking urgency and emphasizing formalities while Godzilla rampages (Newell 48). This aspect of the film parallels frustration with Fukushima’s meltdown, as the Fukushima Nuclear Accident Independent Investigation Commission in 2012 stated the incident was a result of the facility’s operator, regulators, and the government “failing to correctly develop the most basic safety requirements — such as assessing the probability of damage, preparing for containing collateral damage from such a disaster, and developing evacuation plans” (qtd. in Newell 48). Godzilla once again proved to have the capability to be used in a multitude of manners to express emotions about relevant cultural and historical moments, and transcended being a monster movie to being a nuanced social commentary.
Following an anime trilogy of films concluding in 2018 that failed to meet expectations, the Reiwa era would begin its wait until its next blockbuster. Godzilla: Minus One (2023) would release and break even more new grounds for Godzilla in the 21st century. It was the first and so far, only Godzilla film to win an Oscar, receive great fan and critical acclaim, and once again stayed faithful to Godzilla’s roots while utilizing the character for expression for new ideas. Minus One is a dramatic anti-war story with stunning visuals and compelling human narratives, and critiques wartime and postwar Japanese government (Tsutsui 13). The story is not a Godzilla story, but rather a story that uses Godzilla to explore themes of survivor’s guilt, PTSD, and the value of human life (“Up From The Depths Reviews | Godzilla Minus One (2023)”2:25-2:35). From 1954 to 2023, Godzilla still has the capability to be relevant.

Godzilla, undoubtedly, strayed away from its serious roots into borderline absurdity and silliness. What this change means, what it says about the character, and what it shows about the cultures surrounding it, are extremely important. Understanding these changes involve analysis of films with absurd plotlines that simply existed to keep Toho profitable financially. Nonetheless, heart, thought, and spirit were consistently poured into the creation of these films, and they should be understood for what they were in the time and place they were created. The different interpretations of Godzilla throughout the franchise establish an intertextuality that is unique and intriguing. The franchise’s perception may not be an entirely scholarly one, but it is worthy of more recognition for its complexity and cultural relevance and is in a similar category to Maus.
A comparison of Maus and the Godzilla franchise is more relevant than it may seem. Maus has no adaptation or continuation, depicts a story that is entirely non-fictional, and is taken very seriously among critics and academics. The Godzilla franchise is fictional and has many continuations and adaptations of previously established ideas. Godzilla (1954) often receives its credit for being ahead of its time and pioneering the kaiju genre, but the Godzilla franchise overall is often seen as a series of unserious popcorn flicks meant mainly to entertain. Through a closer glance, it can be seen that this perception of Godzilla is mainly created by a cultural gap between Japanese and American viewers and a lack of understanding of Godzilla. The TriStar Productions release Godzilla (1998) and its creative process highlight this disparity, as screenwriter Terry Rossio stated he was not a fan of the series, and his script that took away the allegorical significance of Godzilla made this apparent. American releases of Godzilla films did not help this disparity in understanding, as films were often dubbed inadequately and recut (often due to political reasons) to make significant changes to the original work (Kalat 24). Later Showa Era films that became entirely unserious also likely contributed to the franchise’s reputation. Nonetheless, understanding that biased perceptions does not make the Godzilla franchise have less merit as an excellent unorthodox allegory, and it is capable of standing tall as a comparable work to Maus.
The significant trait that Maus and Godzilla have in common is that they utilize unorthodox allegories and mediums to effectively express ideas about serious topics. It is not uncommon for creative works to utilize untraditional allegories or methods to express ideas, but what makes Maus and Godzilla so poignant is their contributions to their respective genres and their ideas. Maus broke graphic novels into the mainstream and formulated a new approach to Holocaust storytelling, while Godzilla launched a new genre of kaiju films in Japan and helped Japan make sense of and tell their story of being nuclear disaster victims. The intertextuality of Maus is well known, but the merit and complexity of the intertextuality of Godzilla is less understood on a wide level.

Godzilla, as a character, has been utilized in many different manners. The web of ideas about nuclear disaster was started in the 1954 film, and then the series began to use Godzilla in other historical trauma contexts. In Return of Godzilla (1984), the prime minister is surrounded by the Soviet Union leader and the United States leader, urging him to use nuclear weaponry to defeat Godzilla. Godzilla as a symbol is now being used in the context of the cold war: Japan was geographically and culturally Eastern but politically aligned with the Western allies, putting them in the middle of the two opposing forces of the Cold War (Kalat 11). The scene is powerful as the way it emphasizes the urges of the Soviet and United States leaders, rather than the face and reaction of the prime minister’s, creating an atmospheric and visual tension to reflect Japan’s real world feelings of the time (Kalat 163).
Another key similarity of the two works is the protection harbored by their respective creators. Just as Art Spiegelman is protective of Maus and is unwilling for it to be adapted, Toho takes its autonomy of Godzilla seriously. During Toho’s hiatus, Marvel purchased the rights to the character Godzilla (and no one else) and published a comic book running from 1977 to 1979. Godzilla’s design was a giant green dinosaur that more closely resembled a tyrannosaurus rex; Marvel attempted to recreate the traditional evil Godzilla, but on multiple occasions anthropomorphized Godzilla similar to the Showa era (Kalat 153). Stan Lee described the Godzilla comics as “lighter, more ‘fun’” compared to “‘serious’ books like Master of Kung Fu” (qtd. in Kalat 154). This perception likely influenced the development of the Godzilla comics, which left Toho frustrated and resulted in them not renewing Marvel’s licensing agreement (Kalat 154).

©Marvel
Toho’s care and pride in owning Godzilla is also clear in Godzilla: Final Wars (2004). With frustration among Toho and fans brewing due to TriStar’s treatment of Godzilla in their failed 1998 film, Toho purchased the rights to the 1998 Godzilla. In the 2004 film, the 1998 Godzilla is now titled “Zilla,” thus taking the “God” out of its name, essentially stating that the 1998 Godzilla was inadequate and should not be correlated with the image of Godzilla already established. In the film, Godzilla battles against Zilla, in a short scene where Godzilla utterly decimates Zilla almost instantly (“Godzilla (Japanese Original) VS Zilla (American Remake)” 0:00-0:45). Through this mocking of the American Godzilla, and everything involved in the process of the 1998 film that was not respectful to the image of Godzilla, Toho asserted its dominance as creator and owner of its cultural symbol. This instance, however, does not signify that Toho were completely unwilling to let foreign parties create Godzilla works, as later on the well-acclaimed Legendary Pictures Godzilla (2014) would earn Toho’s respect back and Toho would allow future Monsterverse films to use the signature Godzilla theme.
Toho’s desire was that other parties would share the tact, respect, and care they did with handling Godzilla, something that the 1998 film did not do. When it comes to Maus, Spiegelman’s fear was that his work functioned better as a graphic novel, and he wanted his work to be under his autonomy. Perhaps, the handling of Godzilla by foreign parties can reaffirm fears of inadequate interpretation and transformation of one’s work. Godzilla had a great cultural gap and biased prejudice in America due to external factors like inadequate dubbing and cultural differences. Many times, Godzilla films that got American releases were recut to the point where the Japanese essence and significant messaging of the film, their most important trait, was completely removed, such as Godzilla, King of the Monsters! (1956), and Godzilla 1985 (1985) (Kalat 3). Toho allowed these foreign versions to exist out of a need for profit, but these films underwent these cuts due to a desire for Western appeal. These same reasons for inadequate transformation of Godzilla works would potentially harm a Maus adaptation, something that Spiegelman has the right to fear.
The comparison of these two works is vastly significant. Both works revolutionize storytelling in their respective genres and present new, untraditional ways of looking at serious topics. Maus and Godzilla utilize to a great extent the mediums that they are in, pedaling the point that graphic novels and monster movies should become viewed as more serious art forms. Maus has earned this distinction, but Godzilla is still working towards it, despite having the same merits. These works open the door for more unorthodox allegories and mediums to earn notoriety and literary inclusion, as this would only be beneficial for advancing the scope understanding of intertextuality and unique storytelling.

©Legendary Pictures
Maus has grown into becoming a popular choice for teaching graphic novels in the classroom. Terry Bar, who consistently uses Maus as part of his Holocaust course at a private liberal arts college, states, “I believe firmly that students feel the complexity of Maus and that a graphic novel can do justice to the most profound subject” (83). Maus has great strength as a literary text that not only holds up its own worth in a classroom but opens the door for other graphic novels to be welcomed in the classroom. For middle school and high school age groups, graphic novels are increasingly beneficial because they are of high interest to students and promote utilization of diverse reading skills (Bucher 68). The importance of student interest in reading material is undeniable, so it is only sensible and perhaps necessary in the increasingly visual era that educators move towards more graphic novel inclusion in the classroom. Some educators, however, may fear an emphasis on graphic novels will move students away from reading traditional novels. Graphic novels reflect many genres of traditional literature, and they present an efficient gateway to get students more enthralled with reading. A teacher could then segway into other traditional works and even compare them to strengthen student literacy skills.
Maus and other graphic novels have begun an upward trend of literary inclusion and classroom incorporation, but evaluating how a work like Godzilla can fit into literary notoriety and classroom inclusion presents a different challenge. Literary canons have their set hallmark works, but historically and currently have involved a movement of multiplicity and change (Lauter 11). A fantastical work like Godzilla that relies heavily on supernatural elements and has a history of being considered “popcorn entertainment” can prove an obstacle towards serious literary notoriety or inclusion in classrooms. Nonetheless, Godzilla proves the capability of fantastical works and unorthodox mediums to be strong literary works with the same effectiveness as a traditional “canon” work. The character’s vast extension of interpretation and intertextuality provides a baseline for the character to be taught in a multitude of ways. Godzilla also has a large catalogue of graphic novels and comics from publisher IDW, and the original 1954 film story by Shigeru Kayama was recently translated and published in novel form in 2023. There are a multitude of options available to indulge in Godzilla in and out of the classroom that provide insight into the character’s capabilities and literary merit.
An evaluation of Maus and Godzilla reveal astounding capabilities of their respective literary merit and intertextuality. While the two works are very different, they are similar in their utilization of unconventional allegories to express ideas about serious topics. A comparison of the two enhances the respective strengths of both works and highlights the capability and merit of works similar to them. The intertextuality and complexity of Godzilla showcase that the franchise deserves more esteemed recognition than it currently has, and its ability to stand next to a work like Maus enhances this prospect. As the literary canon and classroom curricula continue to evolve, an incorporation of Maus, Godzilla, and works with the same traits as them present newfound benefits to expanding literary understanding and increasing student interest.

Image Source: Quote Fancy
Works Cited
“All Monsters Attack.” Rotten Tomatoes, https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/all_monsters_attack.
“Art Spiegelman.” Gale Literature: Contemporary Authors, Gale, 2022. Gale Literature: Contemporary Authors, link.gale.com/apps/doc/H1000093771/CA?u=nysl_li_molloy&sid=bookmark-CA&xid=067eb915. Accessed 25 Feb. 2025.
Barr, T. “Teaching Maus to a Holocaust Class” in Tabachnick, Stephen E., editor. Teaching the Graphic Novel. The Modern Language Association of America, 2014.
Bucher, Katherine T., and M. Lee Manning. “Bringing Graphic Novels into a School’s Curriculum.” The Clearing House, vol. 78, no. 2, 2004, pp. 67–72. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/30197687.
Chernov, Matthew. “Godzilla: All the Movies Ranked.” Variety, 28 Mar. 2024, variety.com/lists/godzilla-movies-ranked/.
Chute, Hillary. “Comics as Literature? Reading Graphic Narrative.” PMLA, vol. 123, no. 2, 2008, pp. 452–65. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/25501865.
Ewert, Jeanne C. “Reading Visual Narrative: Art Spiegelman’s ‘Maus.’” Narrative, vol. 8, no. 1, 2000, pp. 87–103. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/20107202.
Durkin, Daniel J., III., Godzilla and the Cold War: Japanese Memory, Fear, and Anxiety in Toho Studio’s Godzilla Franchise, 1954-2016, 2021. Bowling Green State University, PhD dissertation. https://www.proquest.com/dissertations-theses/godzilla-cold-war-japanese-memory-fear-anxiety/docview/2553546379/se-2.
“Godzilla (Japanese Original) vs Zilla (American Remake).” YouTube, uploaded by RuneScapeNovice, 8 Dec. 2012, www.youtube.com/watch?v=zPxhdo4HDgg.
“Godzilla vs King Ghidorah (1991) – Best Scene.” YouTube, uploaded by Endgame167, 16 Dec. 2012, www.youtube.com/watch?v=bYzc3aMI-y4
Gordon, Joan. “Surviving the Survivor: Art Spiegelman’s Maus.” Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts, vol. 5, no. 2 (18), 1993, pp. 81–89. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43308153. Accessed 9 Mar. 2025.
Honda, Ishirō, director. All Monsters Attack. Toho, 1969.
—. Godzilla. Toho, 1954.
Kalat, David. A Critical History and Filmography of Toho’s Godzilla Series. McFarland, 1997.
Kitamura, Ryuhei, director. Godzilla: Final Wars. Toho, 2004.
Lauter, Paul. “Literary Canon.” Encyclopedia of American Studies, edited by Sharon P. Holland, 1st ed., Johns Hopkins University Press, 2021. Credo Reference, https://search.credoreference.com/articles/Qm9va0FydGljbGU6NjY5NDk=?aid=113963.
Matthews, Amy T. “Triangulation of Memory.” Navigating the Kingdom of Night, University of Adelaide Press, 2013, pp. 129–38. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.20851/j.ctt1sq5wms.11.
Newell, Hunter L. “Long Live the King: How Godzilla Evolved Through the Cold War to Confront Modern Day Monsters.” SUNY Open Access Repository, 2021, https://soar.suny.edu/handle/20.500.12648/11530.
Ōmori, Kazuki, director. Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah. Toho, 1991.
Orr, Mary. “Intertextuality.” The Encyclopedia of Literary and Cultural Theory, edited by Michael Ryan, 1st ed., Wiley, 2011. Credo Reference, https://search.credoreference.com/articles/Qm9va0FydGljbGU6MTAyODU1NA==?aid=113963.
“Remembering the Heisei Godzilla Series.” YouTube, uploaded by Up from the Depths, 16 May 2018, www.youtube.com/watch?v=pzwCvSnfeCE.
Spiegelman, Art. The Complete Maus. 1996. Penguin, 2003.
“Tear Jerker Moments in Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah.” TV Tropes, 22 Oct. 2023, tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/TearJerker/GodzillaVsKingGhidorah. Accessed 19 Mar. 2025.
“The History and Evolution of Godzilla.” YouTube, uploaded by JustinSVA, 11 Oct. 2017, www.youtube.com/watch?v=mO0zkzaE748.
“The History of All Monsters Attack (1969).” YouTube, uploaded by Big Action Bill, 19 June 2022, www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLJJyUhfNS0.
“The Meaning of Godzilla vs. King Ghidorah.” YouTube, uploaded by Up From the Depths, 12 June 2019, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHpAe4LfG3o&ab_channel=UpFromTheDepths
Tsutsui, William M. “Is Your War Over Now? Nationalism, Nostalgia, and Japan’s Long Postwar from Gojira (1954) to Godzilla Minus One (2023).” Humanities, vol. 13, no. 6, 2024, article 158, https://doi.org/10.3390/h13060158.
“Up from the Depths Reviews | Godzilla (1954).” YouTube, uploaded by Up from the Depths, 19 Aug. 2018, www.youtube.com/watch?v=o15Tzn2F5zo.
“Up from the Depths Reviews | Godzilla (2014).” YouTube, 8 May 2019, www.youtube.com/watch?v=dsOxMccI42g. Accessed 24 Mar. 2025.
“Up from the Depths Reviews | Godzilla: Final Wars (2004).” YouTube, uploaded by Up from the Depths, 1 May 2019, www.youtube.com/watch?v=HK_mbfaZ9FE.
“Up from the Depths Reviews | Godzilla Minus One (2023).” YouTube, 9 May 2024, www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6mlIInFWJI.
Ursini, Francesco-Alessio. “Themes, Focalization and the Flow of Information: The Case of Shingeki no Kyojin.” The Comics Grid: Journal of Comics Scholarship, vol. 7, no. 1, 15 Mar. 2017. Gale OneFile: Pop Culture Studies, dx.doi.org.molloy.idm.oclc.org/10.16995/cg.83.
Weinstein, Max. “Art Spiegelman Says He Won’t Adapt ‘Maus’ for the Screen.” Animation World Network, 3 Feb. 2019, www.awn.com/news/art-spiegelman-says-he-wont-adapt-maus-screen.


